Racial purity is “scientifically meaningless,” say 8,000 geneticists American geneticists take a stand against the misuse of their science by racists.
Humans have a natural tendency to separate ourselves from others via categories such as skin color, cultural background, ancestry, location ,education, political affliation & socioeconomic level etc…yet we are all far more alike on a genetic level than most of us understand (including myself). I recognized many years ago that all of us have some form of an M in our palms. When I have pointed this out to people, it really is a magical moment of commonality. When we take the time to get to know another despite perceived differences we can identify the common threads in our stories, our emotional, mental, physical and spiritual lives, as well as our challenges and hopes.
The following article makes it clear that the intermixing of human genes over millennia has caused a magnificent collection of combinations creating no truly “pure” representation of the race we identify with. Thanks to Ancestry and 23&Me so many of us can see we are a brilliant mix of so many places and people. As with dogs, interbreeding creates the healthiest dogs as opposed to “pure breeds”.
“The science of genetics deals with the very small, but cannot escape the larger societal implications that are often catalyzed by its research. Genetics have been invoked (incorrectly) by the growing white supremacy movement in the U.S. in order to justify its ideas about race. In an attempt to disassociate genetics from such views, the American Society of Human Genetics (ASHG)has come out with a statement that declares the concept of “racial purity” meaningless from a scientific standpoint.
The society, which is the largest professional organization of scientists who work in human genetics, has about 8,000 members. Its statement calls the ideas of white supremacists about genetics “bogus,” “discredited” and “distorted”. The ASHG also makes a clear point that as far as the scientists are concerned, the age-old concept of race is wrong and humans cannot be split into subcategories that would be biologically different from each other.
“The study of human genetics challenges the traditional concept of different races of humans as biologically separate and distinct,” write the scientists.
The reason there is no race purity is due to the genetic intermixing of populations that results from constant migrations which have taken place all throughout human history. The constant movement of people resulted in very blurry genetic lines between groups.
And if you’re wondering whether this is something controversial in the scientific community, the statement goes on to say that the fact that there are no completely separate races is supported by decades of research, including six recent studies like the 2017 paper from the Center for Research on Genomics and Global Health, directly titled “Human ancestry correlates with language and reveals that race is not an objective genomic classifier”.
Race, according to the scientists, is a “social construct” that is derived from people self-identifying with races based on physical appearance. Furthermore, there is no genetics-based support for claiming one group superior to another, expound the researchers.
Credit: Youtube/Museum of the Moving Image
White supremacists chugging milk. NYC. 2017.
The need for actual geneticists to take a stand is driven by the spread of racial purity myths that have been soundly disproven by science. Unexpectedly, one such strange idea taking hold relates to drinking milk.Some white nationalists believe that the ability to digest lactose in milk is somehow a characteristic of racial identity. They twist genetic research to conclude that it’s a trait of white people to drink and digest milk. And if you’re not able to do it, you might as well go back to where you came from. This tends to be especially directed at people of African ancestry, writes Amy Harmon in the New York Times.
This kind of bizarre thinking led to the phenomenon of milk chugging, whereby gathered white supremacists down gallons of milk. Of course, it bears pointing out that lactase – the enzyme that breaks down milk is not specific to white people and is found in 35% of the world’s population.
Other racist misuses of genetics include the tropes of “natural” racial hierarchies – this kind of thinking was employed to justify slavery, the American eugenics movement, and the “racial hygiene” laws of the Nazis.
To continue debunking such ideas, the society of geneticists encourages its members to become more active politically and socially to “reflect their values”.
You can read their statement in the American Journal of Human Genetics.
Big Think. PAUL RATNER 24 October, 2018